Bangladesh-India Friendship in Crisis? Smaller nations within India’s regional sphere of influence are caught in a power competition between India and China. Despite India’s “Neighborhood First” policy, New Delhi’s support for the small states in its backyard pales compared to Beijing’s massive military and economic aid, which pushes these states – once closer to India – to now strengthen their diplomatic ties with China. India views the states in its immediate neighborhood as vassal states and attempts to increase its dominance by reducing their autonomy. China, on the other hand, benefits from the anxieties of these small states by offering economic development and security with room for political maneuvering. With China as a less threatening alternative to acquire military and economic support, these countries now balance between the two powers to reduce their dependency.
This has become evident in recent years: a pro-Chinese government in
Nepal, rising anti-Indian sentiments in the
Maldives alongside a growing Chinese presence in its exclusive economic zones and the oceanic boundaries, and Bhutan’s recognition of China’s stake in the
Doklam dispute. In Afghanistan, the Taliban stronghold has limited opportunities for Indian influence, and a politically vulnerable Bangladesh is at risk of aligning more closely with China.
Awami League had enjoyed a close relationship with India due to cultural, geographic and historical ties. India provided arms and financial assistance to Awami League and the Mukti Bahini (freedom fighters) during the 1971 Liberation War and housed
12-15 million Bengali refugees in the Indian states of Assam and West Bengal. The huge influx of Bengali Muslim refugees caused alarm to the
indigenous Assamese population who feared the refugees would distort the demographic composition of the region. This has led to persecution of Bengali-speaking Muslims over the decades. They are mockingly called ‘Bangladeshis’ or treated as illegal immigrants – even though some of them have been living in India since its partition in 1947 or are legal immigrants.
Tensions have also led to anti-Indian terrorist activities in these provinces, with terrorists finding safe havens across the border in Bangladesh. Wajid’s government has always extended support to India in this regard: curbing anti-Indian activities occurring on Bangladeshi territory and
extraditing leaders of anti-Indian movements who were found operating from Bangladesh. It was also Wajid’s attempt to portray herself as a secularist who was staunchly committed to fighting Islamist elements on her country’s soil. However, maintaining this goodwill is increasingly difficult as dissatisfaction grows within both states.
Persecution of Bengali Muslim refugees and illegal Bangladeshis has resulted in social discord. Indian border guards are
accused of killing undocumented Bangladeshis. The severity of this situation has intensified a contentious issue in Indian domestic politics. To address this issue and fulfil a major electoral promise, the Modi government created the
National Register of Citizens (NRC) in 2019. The NRC was used as a political tool by Modi’s government to threaten the deportation of all Indian Muslims, regardless of ethnicity, who are unable to produce satisfactory legal documents. This, together with the
anti-Muslim rhetoric of the Modi government, has spurred anger within the Bengali-speaking Muslim majority population of Bangladesh. Assaults on the minority Hindu community in Bangladesh have occurred, despite the protection provided under the Awami League’s rule. With Wajid ousted, the Hindu community is more vulnerable to attacks by
angry mobs. Since her resignation on 5 August,
Hindu households,
reports show that temples and businesses have been targeted in at least 200 attacks across 52 districts in Bangladesh.
The political turmoil has created an opportunity for the Awami League’s rivals, the controversial Jamat e Islami and Bangladesh National Party (BNP), who have been historically aligned more closely with Pakistan than with India. In fact, the leader of the BNP, Khalida Zia – who was released from house arrest immediately after Wajid’s resignation –
stated that cordial relations between India and Bangladesh could be jeopardized if India continues to harbor Wajid. These issues, which could be a bone of contention for Bangladesh and India, are seen as strategic opportunities ready to be exploited by China.
An Opportunity for ChinaIn principle, Beijing is usually displeased when a government is overthrown by a popular uprising. However, in this case, the potential benefits of the situation in Bangladesh may outweigh their concerns. China has worked to
improve its strategic partnership with Dhaka. Over the past decade, India and China have made a series of investments and offered loans for infrastructure and development in Bangladesh, with China’s economic might outmatching Indian offers.
In 2016, when India offered a $2 billion credit to Bangladesh, China countered the offer with a
$40 billion investment, of which $24 billion was a development loan. Similarly, when India failed to uphold its promise of delivering COVID-19 vaccines, China stepped in to fill the gap.
30% of Bangladeshi’s
imports are from China, compared with 14% from India. China granted duty-free access to its markets for 97% of Bangladeshi products. It has also increased its military hardware supplies and direct
investments in the country. Both countries are now deepening engagements so Bangladesh could benefit from China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) projects. Nine infrastructure projects, including the Padma Bridge project, are included in China’s BRI. Bangladesh erred on the side of caution by negotiating a low
interest rateof 1.23% and balancing Chinese investment loans with those received from India and Japan. The development of Bangladeshi ports and an overland economic corridor will also provide China with access to the Bay of Bengal and the Indian Ocean. This access, which could serve as an alternative to the Strait of Malacca, holds significant geostrategic importance, heightening India’s concerns.